How to choose a CBT or EMDR therapist

F1000020 43

 

Common FAQs for CBT and EMDR Therapy

Which is better – CBT or EMDR?

Both are highly effective therapies for treating anxiety, depression and trauma. CBT involves understanding what you think, how you feel and how you respond in your present day life so that you can find ways to challenge your thinking and behaviours to change how you feel.

For PTSD, CBT guides you to update the trauma memory through reliving the worst parts and updating the beliefs you held at the time of the trauma using information gained from powerful cognitive challenging. 

EMDR involves starting with current symptoms and beliefs which trouble you the most and linking those symptoms to early memories. By updating early memories using bilateral stimulation, you start to feel differently and deal with situations differently.

For PTSD treatment, specific parts of the trauma memory is targeted using bilateral stimulation to link it up with information that you hold already hold about yourself, so that the memory can be laid down into autobiographical memory and the emotional intensity is reduced.

EMDR therapy for single traumatic events reduces the overall length of therapy by 1/3.

Can CBT and EMDR be used together?

Yes. CBT teaches awareness of thoughts and how to challenge as well as new coping skills. EMDR helps heal memories where negative core beliefs were either formed or confirmed. Once these are processed and distress is reduced, it is possible to use CBT skills to maintain lasting changes gained in therapy.

How do I know if CBT or EMDR is right for me?

Sometimes this depends on your previous experience of these therapies, how well you are able to engage in talking therapy as well as how long you have been struggling.

If your main difficulty is anxiety, unhelfpul thought patterns and depression, CBT is often ideal. However for more chronic difficulties related to childhood trauma or unresolved trauma with flashbacks, EMDR may be more suitable.

How to choose a qualified CBT Therapist

When choosing a private CBT therapist be sure to check the therapist’s credentials. 

A fully qualified CBT Therapist will have trained with an Accredited Level 2 or above, training course in CBT. An accredited course requires certain training standards including the number of closely supervised CBT sessions to have taken place prior to qualification.

Accreditation with the British Association of Cognitive and Behavioural of Psychotherapy (BABCP) is a demonstration of competency and achievement of best practice standards in CBT. 

All accredited CBT therapists are listed by name at www.cbtregisteruk.co.uk

How to choose a qualified EMDR therapist

Qualified EMDR Therapists will have completed 3 stages of ‘Standard Accredited Training’, which is accredited by the EMDR Europe for British and European practitioners or EMDRIA for US practitioners.

To become and EMDR Europe Accredited Practitioner an EMDR Therapist is required to have completed a certain number of closely supervised hours of EMDR Therapy and to have demonstrated a number of competencies during their supervised practice.

To find an EMDR Europe Accredited Practitioner use the following link:

Find a therapist

How to choose a good fit for you

  • Is the therapist qualified, certified and accredited in CBT or EMDR?
  • How soon is “now”? Are you happy to join a waiting list or is the problem becoming acute?
  • Is gender a concern? Some people will not be comfortable with a male or female stranger discussing intimate matters. It’s your decision.
  • Is sexuality an issue? Talking through problems with someone who identifies as lesbian, for example, may be important.
  • Do you share a common language? If you are British Indian, for example, and want to discuss a sensitive cultural matter, finding a therapist who speaks Hindi can be reassuring.
  • Would you be happy with sessions where the therapist is mostly silent, or do you want interaction?
  • How much are you happy to pay?
  • If you have private health insurance, this could be an option for payment.  Check with your provider first.
  • Would you prefer your therapist to be a similar age to you, older, or younger?
  • Do you want to focus on problems in the here and now or something that happened in the past?
  • Do you want to attend in a group, as a couple or alone?
  • Would you prefer to see someone close or are you interested in using online appointments?